Choose a stipulation (steel cage, TLC, tables, etc.) match. Complete two signature moves and two finishers and win the match to earn at least 1,000 points. Use a lot of finishers and get OMG! Moments in the same match.
Play as Adrian Neville, Bo Dallas, Corey Graves, Rusev, or Sami Zayn and defeat John Cena. This can be done under any difficulty setting in Universe mode.
Select a one on one match. Beat down your opponent and knock him to the ground. Pick him up so he is in a groggy state. You should be prompted to do a pin using the Right Analog-stick. Either tap it Up or Down to do a leverage pin. Get a three count with the leverage pin.
You have three different Chain Holds you can win by pressing either X, Y, or B  or Square, Triangle, Circle  PlayStation4  to Grapple your opponent at the start of the match to start a chain hold. Choose either one and win, then strike or wrench your opponent using X or A  or Square or X  PlayStation4  . Win the struggle and move him into the next position then wrench or strike him again. Release the hold by pressing LB  or L1  PlayStation4  then grapple again. This time, try to win a different chain hold. Keep grappling with your opponent and repeating the process until "Ringmaster" is earned. This may require a few attempts. Note: You can always Chain Hold as long as your stamina or your opponent's stamina bar does not get lower than the first bar. Consider going outside and waiting until you and your opponent refills their bar before trying again.
Complete the indicated task to unlock the corresponding extra.